Which screwdriver is better, Makita or Hitachi? How to choose a cordless screwdriver Makita or Hitachi hammer drill, which is better

Both experienced and novice craftsmen regularly face the problem of choosing a tool. You can, of course, ask your colleagues, but there are so many people, so many opinions. IN this review we will try to be as objective as possible and compare two world-famous brands. Two Japanese will compete in single combat - and. These are companies with a hundred-year history and vast experience in the field of equipment production.

Assortment

Power tools are just one of the areas of the giant Hitachi corporation. The company is also known for its electronics, climate control equipment and heavy construction equipment: excavators, cranes, etc. The range of power tools covers all popular categories. Less represented hand tool, machine tools and pneumatics.

Now the manufacturer is updating its range with battery-powered equipment: screwdrivers, planes, grinders, as well as garden trimmers, blowers and hedge trimmers. A series of tools with advanced brushless motors has been released - you can recognize it by white color housings. Separately, Hitachi’s line of generators is worth highlighting. This is first class, reliable equipment.

Unlike its competitor, Makita deals exclusively with tools and equipment (both electric and gasoline). But its range is very diverse. For example, in the line of heavy hammer drills alone there are more than 20 models. Not forgotten either specialized tool: diamond and band saws, concrete compactors, etc. More attention is paid to the introduction of technological innovations and the development of fundamentally new designs.

Purpose

The products of both manufacturers are addressed to professionals. Therefore, there is no doubt about its reliability and wear resistance. Whether it's a Hitachi or a Makita, the tool is designed to withstand heavy-duty use and challenging tasks.

Popular models

Hitachi or Makita, like any other manufacturer, can have their successes and failures. This is most clearly manifested in specific products. Let's take, for example, one of the most popular Hitachi cordless screwdrivers - DS12DFV3. The model is equipped with 2 batteries, fits well in the hand and is extremely reliable.

The Hitachi DH24PB3 hammer drill, a lightweight dual-mode model, was also in great demand. The only disadvantage of the tool is the inconvenient location and tight movement of the switch. This defect has been eliminated in new models.

One of Makita's most successful models is the HR 2450 three-mode rotary hammer. Its power, ergonomics and functionality deserve the highest praise. Among the grinders, we can highlight the lightweight Makita GA 5030 model with a 125 mm disc. The tool is comfortable, maneuverable and low vibration.

Conclusions

So, we compared the two brands according to several criteria. Both companies are from Japan, have been on the market for many years and produce tools for professionals. Quite a lot in common - but at the same time, Makita is among the leaders on the Russian market, while Hitachi is noticeably lagging behind. In favor of Makita, we can say that the company provides generally more stable quality, affordable spare parts and best service. However, some models of Hitachi power tools enjoy enviable success, so this manufacturer should not be discounted.

The question of which is better in price - Makita or Hitachi - is also not easy to answer. Products belong to approximately one price segment, although on average Hitachi is slightly cheaper. We recommend choosing not a brand, but comparing similar models from 2 brands - this will allow you to make a more informed decision.

Choosing a cordless screwdriver

In fact, most users prefer to have construction tools in their household universal tool. The motives for such zeal are completely natural: it is more rational to have one tool in the household that can change several. The cost savings on closet shelf space are obvious. But everything that exists has both its advantages and disadvantages; a universal tool powered by batteries is no exception to this generally accepted rule. The apartment renovation website will tell you how to choose the right screwdriver and what is best to take into account. Share your views and leave reviews.

Therefore, the user needs to ensure that when choosing a universal tool, he deliberately allows for the averaging of certain features according to which the quality of the tool is assessed, such as drilling speed or, in other words, impact force. Apart from this, some properties of the tool become simply incomparable; nettle drilling with impact does not drill holes of small diameter. Cordless screwdriver: which one is better to choose, rating 2017 professional models and for the home. But the user enjoys all the advantages inherent in versatility, such as:

Battery-powered tools ensure autonomy from household electrical outlets
The multifunctionality of the tool provides wide possibilities for its implementation
Simplicity is not precision

And all this is far from a complete list of the capabilities of universal tools. Manufacturers now offer a wide range of different models of cordless universal tools such as: screwdrivers, grinding machines, planes and nothing else. In reality, there is a tendency to replace conventional corded tools with cordless tools, not so much in everyday life, but in production and not in industry. According to the text of the article, taking into account the relevance of the issue, the right choice tools, the properties and characteristics of cordless screwdrivers are carefully considered.

Cordless universal tools - advantages and disadvantages

It goes without saying that best choice The tool is immediately determined by the tasks the solution of which the tool must provide, not, like ladies, by the criteria for its future operation (everyday use or the solution of professional problems). A clear awareness of future operating conditions is all the more important, taking into account that the price of functional household tools is not much different from the price of professional cordless screwdrivers. It is completely reasonable for the question to arise - what is the difference between a professional tool and household models. The main difference is manifested in the fact that a professional screwdriver is able to withstand longer loads and more gentle handling.

These characteristics do not distinguish a professional model from a regular one, which is why some Russian automobile manufacturers indicate in their technical data sheets that their product does not lose its functionality after falling from a certain height. It should also be taken into account that even in the circumstances of repair, a tool created for domestic needs is used less actively than in residential premises. But this highest level of strength and reliability is ensured due to functionality. Therefore, professional tools are less functional than household ones.

To understand the essence of the issue more clearly, you need to analyze the situation by considering a specific example. Let's imagine that a certain furniture workshop received a batch of universal cordless screwdrivers of the QUATTRO brand, who where are these 4 screwdrivers in one of the BlackDecker KC2002FK brand.

Upon superficial examination, it seems that the furniture creation was equipped with wonderful appliances produced by famous brand, this is not where they saved a completely decent amount of money (the price of the set is 6,000 rubles, although the instrument itself is not much cheaper). But this judgment is rather superficial. Cordless screwdriver: which one is better to choose, rating of 2017 professional models and for home. Let's look at the question more thoroughly. In production, often in a day's work you have to do the same type of operations, plan wood, or install finished products, as it is also called, solve issues of packaging products. It’s easy to imagine that to perform these same functions, only one tool is required (nettle, jigsaw, plane, screwdriver, etc.). It becomes clear to our client if we compare the properties of a screwdriver with BlackDecker KC2002FK attachments not the properties of a separate tool. The Myth universal cordless screwdriver is chosen by those who need to use individual components more than once, in addition to the Myth tool itself.

For greater clarity, it makes sense to look at the products that our client has to make of the same brand, and directly the BlackDecker CP12K screwdriver, the price of which is 3.5 thousand rubles. A screwdriver type KC2002FK uses a battery with a capacity of 1.5 Ampere/hour not a voltage of 14.4 V, although the non-universal model uses a battery with a capacity of 1.5 Ampere/hour not a voltage of 12 V, as annoying as it may sound, the value of its torque is 16 Nm, but a more massive universal screwdriver is only 10.5 Nm. The first significant sacrifice to ensure the versatility of the device.

The universal tool is not used like a jigsaw, for which ladies like it, there are no special requirements for it. The jigsaw from the same company, KS999EK, has a power of 600 W, and the adjustable speed of the blade strokes varies from 0 to 3200 strokes/min.

The attachment of the universal device shows the same stroke rate (3000 strokes/min), but with its help there is the option of cutting material to a depth of up to 38 mm, and with a special jigsaw wood is cut up to 65 mm.

To whom the best option will choose this instance? The universal screwdriver with BlackDecker KC2002FK attachments is an ideal tool for DIY use, in which it is used only in cases beyond one’s control, that is, quite occasionally. Its introduction in production makes no sense, therefore, in the professional environment, special tools equipped with the same type of battery packs that do not perform strictly defined, standard functions have become widespread.

Review of professional screwdrivers

Read also

The optimal approach that allows you to save money was shown by the BOSCH company, which released a model line of tools that are powered by the battery of a GSR 18 VE-2-LI Professional screwdriver. Note that the cost savings are very significant, taking into account the higher price of a modern Li-Ion battery. Thus, purchasing additional tool this company no longer needs to receive an additional battery.

Makita vs Hitachi / Which screwdriver to choose? /force control clutch test

Makita vs Hitachi, force adjustment clutch test, comparing models DS10DAL and DF300DWE Cordless

Comparison of 10.8 screwdrivers Makita, Bosch, Dewalt, Hitachi

The following models of Bosch screwdrivers are presented in comparison: GSR 1000 GSB 120-Li GSR 12V-20 V-EC L-B GSR

How to choose the right cordless screwdriver

After considering the main parameters of universal cordless tools, we will carefully consider choosing a cordless screwdriver, and we will look at the characteristics that will allow you to use the tool not only at home, but also for commercial purposes.

We will limit our consideration to products equipped with NiCd batteries, which are actually in wide demand, because, despite our clients having their advantages, Li-Ion batteries, due to their high price, are not particularly popular. Cordless screwdriver: which one is better to choose, rating of 2017 professional models and for home. The main parameters to which you should focus your own professionalism in the process of choosing a tool are:

The tool is equipped with 2.7 batteries with a voltage value of less than 2 12V
Availability of a charger capable of returning the model to functionality in 1 hour
The tool is equipped with a huge number of steps (tightening forces) with the use of which the frequency of the torque is adjusted
Highest value torque
Type of chuck the tool is equipped with
Multiple rotation speeds available

It is recommended that you carefully read the warranty card, because some Russian auto industry does not provide a warranty on car batteries. It is better that the additional equipment includes a set of attachments, 3 batteries and a flashlight.

Armed with all the necessary knowledge, we will evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of the following models of recognizable brands:

Makita 8281DWPE, the cost of which is 5.8 thousand rubles, not equipped with a Li-Ion battery and no shock option.
Cordless screwdriver brand Hitachi DS12DVF3 equipped with flashlights.
Cordless screwdriver brand BOSCH GSR 12-2 Professional.
Cordless screwdriver METABO BSZ 14.4 Impuls, priced at 7 thousand rubles and not owning the rather rare “impulse” option

Unfortunately, due to the exchange rate, the price is no longer relevant and is not for informational purposes only

They are appreciated by the ladies, what remains for our client to do is that the instruments chosen for consideration are distinguished by the highest quality, reliability and durability. Although what remains for our client to do, the screwdrivers listed above belong to the category of professional tools, at a price they are completely affordable for the average user, now we will take a closer look at the properties and decide which one is better to choose.

Cordless screwdriver Makita 8281DWPE

The power source for the tool is the latest generation Li-Ion battery with a voltage of 14.4 V, which is certainly its advantage.

The tool comes with 2 batteries charger, which restores the device’s functionality in just one hour. The screwdriver rotation speed is divided into 3.5 spectrums: the 1st speed spectrum includes speed values from 0 to 400 rpm, and the 2nd spectrum from 0 to 1300 rpm.

Screwdriver equipped with a quick-release chuck (10 mm), equipped with 16 stages of torque setting ( highest value 36 Nm), and the weight of the tool is 1.7 kg. In addition to standard operations, the instrument is equipped with a blow option; it can perform from 0 to 18 thousand blows per minute.

As disadvantages of the tool It is natural to indicate the following:

For a tool equipped with an impact function, the manufacturer supplied it with a rather weak cartridge
Low battery capacity (only 1.3 Ah), which is not enough for intense work
There is a possibility of overlapping by hand ventilation holes, created to cool the electric motor during operation in shock mode, while the ventilation holes are placed so unsuccessfully that they will certainly block if the user’s wide palms pass through
The gear housing of a screwdriver equipped with an impact function is best made of metal.

Hitachi DS12DVF3 cordless screwdriver

The instrument has a somewhat exotic exterior design. This design is not accidental. That’s it, it’s simply not economically feasible to fake the body of the instrument, but exotic linings protect the instrument from falling. Moreover, the pads also provide the screwdriver handle with the necessary ergonomics (the user’s hand is protected from vibrations and does not even sweat during intense work).

Cordless screwdriver BOSCH GSR 12-2 Professional

The instrument is widely known among us and is made in the classic style of the BOSCH company. The product rotation speed spectrum consists of 4.5 subranges, directly speaking:

1st subrange from 0 to 400 rpm
2nd subrange from 0 to 1200 rpm

IN technical equipment The tool includes a quick-release chuck (10 mm), covering the handle of the product with a shock-absorbing pad, not 25 stages of setting the torque, the highest value of which is 27 Nm. The delivery set includes 4 batteries with a capacity of 1.5 Ah and a charger that restores the functionality of the product in 1 hour.

No pad on the back of the instrument body
Somewhat unsuccessful placement of the cartridge, which becomes a prerequisite for inconvenience when replacing the replacement tool

Cordless screwdriver METABO BSZ 14.4 Impuls

The equipment is equipped with a rather rare “pulse” option, which eliminates the need to use a core when drilling, and additionally makes it possible to use the torque, the value of which is 55 Nm. The product rotation speed spectrum consists of 5 subranges, speaking directly:

1st subrange from 0 to 400 rpm
2nd subrange from 0 to 1400 rpm

The tool comes with a non-3.2 battery charger.

The main disadvantages of a screwdriver are:

Slightly oversized body
The button for fixing the battery module is huge, which can cause some inconvenience during operation
Poor placement of ventilation holes at the bottom of the tool, which will quickly become clogged in circumstances of high dust concentration

After analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of the models considered, we summarize our consideration in the final conclusions. The most powerful tool METABO BSZ 14.4 Impuls, equipped useful function“impulse” offers the user enormous capabilities, no matter how annoying it may sound, its high price and weight (2 kg) obviously do not contribute to the popularity of the instrument. The capabilities of the BOSCH GSR 12-2 Professional and Makita 8281DWPE screwdrivers are approximately similar. Note that the lower torque value of a BOSCH brand screwdriver is one hundred percent compensated by the battery capacity, which is not, as it should be, more for a long time work. The Hitachi DS12DVF3 screwdriver is apparently capable of providing maximum comfort during operation, despite its exotic design. Cordless screwdriver: which one is better to choose, rating of 2017 professional models and for home. The well-thought-out ergonomics of the tool contributes to a sense of reliability and confidence, and the flashlight and accessories for attaching the model to a belt only increase the ease of its use. The main advantage of the model is its reasonable price, with all this highest quality execution of the tool. The disadvantage of all 3 models is the “memory” of NiCd type batteries: there is an option to charge the batteries only when their working)) version is discharged. Now draw your conclusions, you understand better than others how to choose the right cordless screwdriver, select suitable option From what was written above, do not forget about safety when working with equipment. Fortune in operation, and also leave your reviews!

Screwdriver Championship in Kharkov

We are reporting from the Metalist stadium. Kharkov is holding a world championship among 14.4 Volt screwdrivers in terms of price-quality ratio. Three legendary models made it to the finals:

The first to enter the torque sector is the representative of the Land of the Rising Sun. It rests against the standard self-tapping screw, and... a brilliant result - 30 Nm! The stands are exploding! With such a torque, it can easily screw a 300 mm screw into a log.

Meanwhile, a representative from Europe is preparing to speak. Bosch GSR14.4VE-2 0.601.993.H20 clicks menacingly with its keyless chuck Auto Lock system, busily approaches the projectile, the stands freeze, the steel gears of the planetary gearbox tense, the self-tapping screw flies into the log, but the judges record the same result as the previous athlete - 30 Nm. Yes, it is impossible to buy our judges. Kharkov masters will not let anyone down!
An American athlete in a yellow and black aggressive suit goes to the start. DeWalt DC 731 KB is in excellent physical shape. It’s clear that he doesn’t care about the cost of victory – he’s ready for anything! This is a turn, this is power! The self-tapping screw passes through the log with a grinding sound. The stands rejoice, anticipating victory. What result did the Kharkov judges record? Wow - 40 Nm! Unprecedented power. A good application for a world record...

Of course, no one will hold such a championship in Kharkov, but from the vast clan of screwdrivers (or cordless drills, to be precise) I would highlight these three models. They are significant in that they have the same battery voltage. This means they can be easily compared.
DeWalt is considered the “old guy” on the market. I had to deal with screwdrivers from this company back in the nineties. Very durable body. After falling from the second floor, he worked as if nothing had happened. The gearbox has two speeds. The lower one is good for tightening, and the higher one for drilling holes. The batteries are ordinary, nickel-manganese, but they good capacity– 2.6 A/h. There is also a fashionable thing today - LED backlight. Convenient when working in places with poor visibility. The price of the “American” is about $250 and it is good for those who work, for example, on roofs.
Bosch GSR14.4VE-2 0.601.993.H20- This is a professional tool. I like it because its body is well balanced and it fits perfectly in the hand. The brushes can be replaced without disassembling the engine (a hint that the screwdriver will survive more than one such replacement). This device also has a two-speed gearbox, steel planetary gears, very smooth start and instant stop. The batteries are no different from the previous model. To be honest, I don't like nickel power supplies. They charge for a long time and have memory. I often found myself in situations where one battery was discharged, and the second had not yet been charged. The price of a screwdriver from the Bosch concern deserves respect - $270. It's perfect for interior work, for example, with drywall. It is often used by furniture makers.

It was not only Kharkov that conquered. Perhaps there is no city where the craftsmen do not squeal from this Japanese.
Even one consultant tried to mess with me, denigrating the entire series of screwdrivers from Hitachi. They say that lately their batteries (lithium-ion, by the way) have begun to quickly fail. Judging by my experience with this tool, the seller simply wanted buyers to pay attention to other models. A chic screwdriver, thought out to the smallest detail! It is small and light. With him you can get close to the most problem areas. Power in combination with a two-speed gearbox and a 22-position force regulator is a real treat for the master. The battery charges in half an hour, and I have been working on my original batteries for three years now. I see no reason to deny myself the pleasure of owning this instrument. The price, by the way, is quite reasonable - $200. Good for both indoor and outdoor work.

However, before you buy a new screwdriver, I imagine different models in relation to the types of work that I mainly do. It is important for me to hold the tool in my hands, because the price does not always determine the ease of use, which is extremely important for the master.

When choosing a tool, especially such as a screwdriver, the question immediately arises of which manufacturer to choose, because there are a great many of them on the market now.

Of course, this question cannot be answered unequivocally and here it is worth looking into the technical characteristics of the instruments. But in this article we will conduct brief overview the most popular brands of screwdrivers, and also, it is worth deciding for what purpose the screwdriver can be used, and from this you can already conclude which model is more suitable.

Before deciding which brand of screwdriver to choose, you must first think about which model you will purchase, professional or household. Many tool manufacturers produce household models that do not have very high power and cannot work for a long time without additional recharging. If the work is carried out at home and not too often, then this model may well be suitable for living conditions. In this case, you will not need to overpay for a screwdriver that will have too high power.

The most popular models on the market recently have been screwdrivers from Makita and Hitachi. And it was they who took the strongest positions in the markets, and showed their models to be of high quality and reliable. The cost of such models ranges from 2500 rubles. But here you should not neglect other models of screwdrivers, and do not think that they have too much low quality. Yes, many companies can offer their models of screwdrivers starting from 700 rubles and with very good characteristics.

Of course, you need to take a more responsible approach to choosing a professional screwdriver, because labor productivity will immediately depend on it. Also here the question immediately arises of which company to choose a screwdriver, and even here you can answer Makita and Hitachi. Such professional tools will have high power as well as battery capacity. And in such models the main difference is additional features, this is backlighting, engine cooling, reverse and much more. Any professional equipment and tools will be too expensive. But such costs cannot always justify their quality, that is, it is better to buy a cheap tool that can last for more than one year.

There is no clear answer to the question of which screwdriver is better. But if you pay attention to the manufacturers, you can also get confused here because now manufacturers present many models that can be either the cheapest or very expensive. But it’s still worth taking a closer look at the screwdrivers from Hitachi and Makita, here you can choose how household tool, and professional who will not let you down in their work.

By purchasing new jigsaw, we must choose one of the many models presented. Models differ in power, weight, technical characteristics and of course – the same price. But besides this, they are produced by various manufacturers.

Of course, those who already use a trusted manufacturer will choose such a manufacturer, but if you are buying such a tool for the first time, then discarding the cheap and non-durable disposable models from little-known companies, we suggest you look at three more practical manufacturers - Bosch, Makita or Hitachi .

It is worth noting that there are professional tools that are more expensive, from manufacturers such as FESTOOL, Mafel, Protoo, but they are very expensive and are needed only by professionals, so we will focus on more affordable models, in terms of price. It should also be said that in terms of quality of work, these models are quite competitive with the above-mentioned ones in many tests.

Looking at the price, it is worth noting that blue Bosch is perhaps the leader if it is not assembled in China or Russia. In principle, price is the first and more correct indicator of the quality and reliability of a tool. To this it is worth adding a well-established brand.

Bosch jigsaws are more balanced and considered the best tool among all companies producing jigsaws in this category, since they have achieved the highest level and comfort when making a cut. In addition, models such as GST 135 CE and GST 135 BCE are equipped with a “Precision Control” system, where, with a simple press of a button, the guides are automatically adjusted to different thickness saw blade for precise guidance and neat corner cuts.

Now let's talk about jigsaws Makita, despite the simple, not outstanding design, all models are designed quite well and the strictly horizontal handle lies securely in the hand. These jigsaws are highly reliable and cope with any task just as well as Bosch jigsaws. The indicators are approximately the same, but the price is lower, so not everyone wants to pay money for a more popular brand.

Makita, like its predecessor, has a minimal level of vibration, it does not jump on the surface, and does not strain the hand. When cutting, it moves easily and clearly. If you read the reviews, they talk about the reliability and durability of the tool. Despite the fact that Makita appeared on the market later, it has long established itself as a best manufacturer professional tool.

We are less familiar with the Hitachi company, but we would like to note the excellent design, even too ultra, of a modern body, which is covered mainly, on most models, with rubber, which is pleasant to the touch, but unfortunately is not very easy to clean after cuts. When studying the reviews, you will find out that it is not very well thought out to protect the engine from small sawdust and when sawing materials made from small particles, for example, the chipboard gearbox becomes clogged with chips and dust.

I must say that many are shocked by the new constructive solution plastic holder for saws, but it is made with high quality and no one reports any breakdowns; at the same time, this jigsaw weighs less than its predecessors. Otherwise, a Hitachi jigsaw with similar technical data is cheaper and this is also important.
Author RVT